Two countertop options that look nice, return good resale value, and resist moisture or heat are “solid surface and quartz”. Both of these options are great, but there’s still a debate on solid surface vs quartz countertops. There are some similarities and differences between quartz and solid surface countertop materials. It’s never “one size fits all”. Both bring their own unique set of pros and cons to the table, which should be carefully considered before making a decision. Or you might not know which option is good as an outdoor counter and which is not.
Let’s discuss both quartz and solid surface countertops in detail for more clarity:
What defines Solid Surface Countertops?
Solid surface countertops are named so because of their homogenous and non-porous nature, which means they remain the same throughout their structure. In other words, a solid surface is an entirely single solid piece. There are no layers or clusters of different patterns. A solid surface’s main property is that it can be used to make countertops with invisible seams.
What Defines Quartz Countertops?
Quartz countertops contain quartz (95%) and binding resins (almost 5%, which also includes pigments). The resins are responsible for binding the quartz particles, and the pigments give them colors. You can find a quartz countertop in a variety of colors and design patterns. It is ideal to be used in kitchens, bathrooms, and many other spaces.
Solid Surface vs Quartz: Possible Similarities And Differences
Let’s Discuss the Similarities First:
Quartz and solid surface countertops look somewhat similar in terms of appearance and non-porous structure. Other than that, some more similarities include
- Both are a bit engineered and a bit natural at the same time.
- Neither of them requires sealing (non-porous structure).
- Both are useful in crafting high-end countertops.
- Both are made of a combination of materials.
- Both are low-maintenance options.
Let's Move Forward To The Differences.
Solid surface and quartz countertops have a lot of similarities, but there are also differences. Both are not differentiated based on a number of factors. Here are some of those factors:
Solid Surface vs Quartz Countertops: Cutting
Cutting each countertop requires specific tools and equipment in addition to expertise. The tools that work on solid countertops might not work on quartz counters:
Solid Surface Countertops
Solid surface countertops can be cut using ordinary saws and routers. You can easily cut using power saws within minutes. Other than that, you may also need seaming kits to join the two solid surface slabs to make one out of them. If you are a beginner, working with a solid surface counter can be much easier for you.
Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops, however, require special tools and equipment for cutting. Those tools are so heavy that a beginner can’t handle them. If you are already a lover of quartz counters, you will surely need an expert for your assistance. Or, you can get ready-made countertops from an expert supplier. On the other hand, if you are already an expert, you can simply order quartz slabs and cut or install them at home.
If you’re on a timeline, the solid surface vs quartz choice may depend on availability; a solid surface can often be fabricated and installed faster.
Our Best seller quartz slabs: Ice Black Quartz, Calacatta Gold Quartz
Quartz vs Solid Surface Countertops: Heat Resistance
The solid surface and quartz countertops are heat resistant and can endure in hot environments. However, there’s a difference in the resistant capability of both that you might not know.
Solid Surface Countertops
Solid surface countertops can surprisingly endure heat up to 320°F (160°C). This is sufficient to convince anyone to use a solid surface counter in the kitchen. However, direct placing of hot pans or other items can damage the countertop. You might notice signs of discoloration, cracking or warping if your countertop is being continuously exposed to extreme heat.
Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops have heat-resistant power for up to 300°F (150°C). These countertops can be used in kitchens, bathrooms, and outdoor areas. However, keep in mind that being heat-resistant does not mean a quartz countertop is heatproof. You can damage a quartz surface if you put hot items or throw hot water on it. But, with proper care, quartz kitchen countertops can last longer than you might think.
For heavy-use areas like kitchen islands, the debate on solid surface vs quartz often favors quartz due to its superior resistance.
Solid surface vs quartz: Seam Visibility
Seams are generally nearly invisible in both quartz and solid surface countertops. However, there are some exceptions to that as well.
Solid Surface Countertops
Solid surface countertops are created using particles that act as a bonding adhesive, making seams invisible to the naked eye. Another reason for the seamless appearance of a solid surface is its poreless structure. You hardly see any grout lines on a solid surface countertop. Thus, if you like countertops on which there are no lines, a solid surface material might be the ideal option for you.
Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops also have a seamless structure and appearance. They aren’t entirely seamless because of the availability of quartz slabs in small pieces. However, if you are an expert or if you know an expert who knows how to install a quartz countertop, you can get that seamless finish. In general, a quartz countertop is seamless and smooth if installed correctly.
Solid Surface vs Quartz: Scratch Resistance
Quartz and solid surface counters are scratch-resistant, but not entirely. There is a difference in the scratch resistance properties of both.
Solid Surface Countertops
Solid surface countertops hardly form scratches on their own. The scratches are formed by cutting directly on the countertop. A solid surface countertop is named solid, but it is relatively softer than many other stones. If you don’t use cutting boards on it, scratches can easily form. So, it is right to say that a solid surface countertop is not scratch-resistant.
Note:
Solid surface material can be easily sanded in case it has mild scratches. You can do buffing at home to restore the original appearance of a solid surface. However, for intense scratches, an expert’s assistance might be required.
Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops won’t scratch much, even if you cut directly onto them. However, continuous hitting of knives or sharp objects can scratch the surface. However, their scratch-resistant capability is considered higher than that of solid-surface countertops. A point to notice is that a quartz counter can still scratch, so it is advised to use a cutting board if you have to use sharp knives.
Note:
Just like solid surface countertops, quartz countertops can also be restored with buffing. You can use a wax cream to hide minimally abrasive scratches. But keep in mind that buffing works for hairline scratches. If the damage is worse, consider calling a countertop expert.
Maintenance is minimal for both materials, but in the solid surface vs quartz discussion, quartz generally requires less attention to prevent scratches and stains.
Solid Surface vs Quartz: Cost
The cost of both quartz and solid surface countertops seems almost similar. However, the cost varies depending on the complexity of the design or installation.
Solid Surface Countertops
The cost of solid surface countertops can start from $30 and go to $150 per square foot. The price can change depending on the color you select or the design you pick. Other than that, if you require thick countertop slabs, you might need to pay some extra money. Investing in good-quality countertops always provides good return value.
Quartz Countertops
The cost of quartz countertops falls between $50 to $250 per square foot. Its price is selected based on its premium appearance and design variations. Moreover, if you require a quartz counter to install in a luxury area and demand a design that complements it perfectly, you might need to invest money accordingly. Choose a countertop that impresses you much, and then pay for it wisely.
Solid Surface vs Quartz: Which One Should You Buy?
A quick way to choose between quartz and solid surface countertops is by comparing their similarities and differences.
When is solid surface a better option?
A solid surface is less expensive than quartz, and you need to renovate a simple or small outdoor kitchen where you won’t need to do much cutting. A solid surface countertop looks perfect in that case, right? Other than that, solid surfaces can be easily cut and moulded into interesting shapes, such as curvy countertops. In the solid surface vs quartz comparison, the solid surface is more customizable for unique shapes and edge profiles.
When to choose quartz?
Quartz is an expensive option, but it gives you a premium look that can boost the value of your property. Moreover, if you need a countertop for a heavy-duty kitchen, quartz might seem like a good option. You can find it in many colours and shapes according to your needs. Moreover, many solid surface vs quartz durability tests reveal that quartz resists scratches and chips better than solid surfaces.
The final decision comes down to your needs and preferences. If either of these options seems fine to you, you should carefully go for it. Both are stunning and a good value for money.
Final Words:
Choosing between the solid surface and quartz countertops should not be a difficult task. Both are good options when it comes to resistance and appearance. There are some differences in these, but still, they can be a good countertop option. You just need to focus on some of the factors before concluding. In some cases, a solid surface countertop can impress you a lot. However, you might want a quartz countertop for your luxury kitchen renovation.
Want to know more about quartz and solid surface countertops? Contact us at SK Stones USA and talk to our experts to explore more!
